The Step-by-Step Funnel Guide to Growing Your Email List from Scratch

So you’ve been told (by every online business coach ever) that you need to “build your list.”

And you get it, in theory.

But when it comes to actually doing it? You open up your email platform, stare at a blank screen, and think “where the hell do I even start?”

Well, that’s exactly what this guide is here to answer.

In this funnel guide, I’m breaking down the step-by-step funnel stages to grow your email list from scratch, even if you’re starting with zero subscribers.

We’ll cover:

• How to attract the right people (not just freebie collectors)
• What to send once they sign up (so you stay top of mind)
• How to turn your list into actual paying clients
  

Let’s build the kind of email funnel that actually does its job, so you can stop relying on algorithms.

Feel 10x more confident about your tech set up for your next live masterclass.

Get the free Masterclass Tech setup checklist designed to walk you through exactly what to do with the tech, in clear, simple terms, so you can stop second-guessing and start growing your audience, your income, and your impact.

Download Now

Why You Should Start Building Your List Now

If you’re waiting until you’ve “got something to sell” before you start growing your list, you’re already behind.

Your email list isn’t just a delivery method for launch day. It’s your warmest, most direct connection to the people who actually want to hear from you.

Let’s break it down:

• Email marketing has an average ROI of 4,200% – it consistently outperforms social media when it comes to actual conversions.
• You own your list – no algorithm, no platform changes.
• Social media is great for visibility, but your email list is where relationships and sales happen.

How to Grow an Email List from Scratch

Now that you know why building your list matters, here’s how to do it.

We’re breaking it down into three core stages: Awareness, Consideration, and Conversion. This is the journey your subscribers take from first contact to paying client.

Stage One: Awareness — Getting in Front of the Right People

Before anyone can join your list, they need to find it, and more importantly, see a reason to care.

This stage is all about visibility. You don’t need to be everywhere, but you do need to show up in the right places with a clear invitation to join your list.

Here’s what to focus on:

• Add email sign-up forms to your website. The best spots are your homepage, footer, contact page, and at the end of your blog posts.
• Use friendly, well-timed pop-ups – think exit-intent pop-ups or a subtle floating bar. Keep it helpful, not annoying.
• Offer something valuable, don’t just say “Join my newsletter.” Give them a reason, like a tip-packed email series, freebie, or a discount.
• Collect emails offline. Events and conferences are still goldmines for genuine leads.
• Choose your main strategy. Are you growing a weekly newsletter, offering a lead magnet, or both? Pick a focus and build around it.
  

You don’t need every tactic on this list, just one that makes sense for where your audience is already showing up.

Stage Two: Consideration — Building Trust and Interest

Once someone joins your list, the last thing you want is to leave them hanging.

This stage is where you warm people up. 

Here’s how to build connection and keep subscribers engaged:

• Give your newsletter a purpose (and a name). Treat it like its own mini-brand. Something memorable that tells people what to expect.
• Use a consistent, easy-to-read format – short, skimmable, and valuable.
• Create a dedicated landing page – sell your newsletter or freebie like it’s a product. Show the benefits, not just “join my list.”
• Send a welcome sequence. Don’t rely on a single confirmation email. Use 3-5 emails to:
  • Confirm their subscription
  • Deliver value
  • Set expectations (how often you’ll email, what they’ll get)
  • Start building trust
    
• Use lead magnets strategically to solve a specific problem your ideal client has.
• Run a referral campaign. Once your list has traction, invite loyal subscribers to share with their audience in exchange for a reward, bonus, or exclusive content.
  

Consistency really matters here. If someone signs up and hears nothing for weeks, they’ll forget you, and your next email will feel like a cold pitch.

Stage Three: Conversion — Turning Subscribers into Customers

Once your subscribers know who you are and what you offer, it’s time to guide them toward taking action.

Here’s how to move from “just value” to real conversions:

• Segment your list. Not everyone is in the same stage. Use tags or behaviours (like clicks, downloads, or purchases) to send the right message to the right people.
• Use strong, clear calls-to-action in your emails. Not every email needs to sell, but every email should have a purpose.
• Optimise checkout page opt-ins. For product-based businesses or digital downloads, offer a bonus or discount at checkout in exchange for an email.
• Time your offers properly. Make sure the email offer aligns with where your subscriber is in their journey. Avoid dropping a sales pitch too soon.
• Use testimonials and proof. If you’re selling via email, show what results your clients or customers have seen. Real stories convert.

Writing Emails That Get Opened and Clicked

You’ve got people on your list. Now your job is to make sure they actually read what you send, and take action when it counts.

Subject Line Best Practices

• Keep it short, clear, and curiosity-driven 
• Use personalisation when it makes sense (first names can work, but so can relevance)
• Test different styles: questions, numbers, bold statements – see what your audience responds to

Want to dig deeper into what makes a subject line actually work? I break it all down in this blog: Guide to Writing Better Email Subject Lines

Email Copy Tips

• Write like a human – conversational, natural, and a little imperfect
• Use short paragraphs and white space so it’s easy to read
• Lead with benefits, not features – tell them why it matters to them
• Share stories when it makes sense, they’re more memorable than a sales pitch

Call-to-Action Strategies

• Stick to one main CTA per email (too many choices = no action)
• Make it clear what’s next: click, reply, book, download
• Match your CTA to where they are in your funnel – don’t push a sale too early
• Make buttons and links obvious (especially on mobile)
  

The best emails feel personal, like something written for your reader, not just blasted to a list.

Choosing the Right Email Marketing Platform

There are a lot of email tools out there. But before you start comparing colour schemes and pricing tables, focus on what you actually need your platform to do.

Here’s what to look for:

• Forms and landing pages – make sure you can easily create sign-up forms and dedicated pages for lead magnets or newsletters.
• Automation and workflows – your platform should let you set up sequences, triggers, and actions (without needing a tech degree).
• Segmentation and tagging – being able to group subscribers by interest, behaviour, or offer is key for sending the right message to the right people.
• Deliverability – not all platforms are created equal. Choose one with a good reputation for landing in inboxes, not spam folders.
• Analytics – you’ll want to track open rates, click-throughs, and conversions so you know what’s working (and what’s not).
• Scalability – choose a platform that can grow with your business, not box you in when you want to expand.
  

Tools I Recommend for Coaches + Service Providers:

• Kajabi – all-in-one platform, perfect if you’re already using it for offers and courses.
• MailerLite – clean, easy to use, solid automations. A great budget-friendly option for getting started.
• Kit – built for creators, strong automation and tagging features, and a nice user experience.
• Flodesk – beautiful templates and branding-first, but limited in more advanced segmentation.

Automating Your Funnel with Triggers and Workflows

Once someone joins your list, you shouldn’t be manually sending emails or wondering if your lead magnet actually landed. Automations take the pressure off and make your funnel work behind the scenes.

Here’s how to set yours up properly:

Welcome Sequences

Set up a series of 3-5 emails that go out automatically when someone signs up. Your welcome sequence should:

• Deliver your lead magnet instantly (don’t make them dig for it)
• Introduce you and what you do
• Set expectations for what kind of emails they’ll receive
• Start building trust and familiarity
• Optionally, introduce your core offer – but keep it light, not pitch-heavy

Lead Magnet Delivery

Whether it’s a guide, template, checklist, or free training, automate this part so it goes out immediately after someone opts in. 

You can deliver it:

• Via a direct download link in the first email
• On a thank-you page (ideal if you want to upsell or introduce the next step)
  

This is your first impression, make it smooth and valuable.

Event-Based Triggers

Set up triggers based on actions your subscriber takes. These let you move people through your funnel based on behaviour rather than guesswork. 

For example:

• Clicked a sales link? → Send a follow-up sequence with FAQs or testimonials
• Signed up for a webinar? → Automate reminders and replay emails
• Purchased your offer? → Remove them from the promo sequence and drop them into your client onboarding flow
  

This keeps your emails relevant and avoids awkward moments like pitching an offer someone has already bought.

Tagging and Segmentation

Automation also lets you tag subscribers based on interests, clicks, downloads, or where they came from. 

This means:

• You can personalise future content and offers
• You won’t blast your whole list with irrelevant info
• You’re building a smarter list, not just a bigger one

List Clean-Up and Re-engagement

Set up automation rules to keep your list healthy:

• Create a re-engagement sequence for people who haven’t opened your last 5-6 emails
• Automatically unsubscribe people who haven’t interacted in 60-90 days
• Ask low-engagement subscribers to update preferences (before removing them)
  

This improves deliverability and keeps your open rates high.

Measuring and Optimising Performance

Once your email funnel is live, don’t just let it run in the background and hope for the best. Your email strategy is only as strong as your ability to measure what’s working and fix what’s not.

Track the Right Metrics

Open rates are a useful starting point, they’ll tell you how strong your subject lines are and give you a sense of deliverability. But they’re not the full picture.

Click-through rate (CTR) is far more telling. If people are clicking, they’re engaged. If they’re not, your content, layout, or call-to-action probably needs work. 

You should also keep an eye on your unsubscribe rate and list growth. A few unsubscribes are normal, but if people are dropping off consistently, your content might be missing the mark, or your frequency may need adjusting.

If you’re not sure which numbers are worth your attention, I break it down in more detail in this blog: Email Marketing Metrics: What to Track and What to Ignore.

Run A/B Tests

Testing helps you improve performance without guessing. Choose one element to experiment with at a time, whether it’s a subject line, CTA, or the format of your email.

Let the test run long enough to collect meaningful data. If your list is small, be patient, it’s better to get clear insight over time than to change direction based on too little information.

Identify Bottlenecks

If subscribers are opening your emails but not clicking, or clicking but not buying, it usually means there’s a disconnect. Maybe your offer isn’t being positioned clearly, or maybe your CTA is too soft.

The goal here is to spot where people are dropping off and why. Go back through your funnel and read your emails from the perspective of someone new to your world. Does it flow? Does it build trust before asking for a decision? Is the offer even relevant to what they signed up for?

Most of the time, a few simple tweaks can make a big difference.

Keep Optimising

Email funnels aren’t “set it and forget it” systems – they’re evolving parts of your business. As your offers change, your welcome sequence and sales emails should evolve too.

Update outdated links, swap in newer lead magnets, rewrite intros if your positioning has shifted, and check your automation triggers are still aligned with your goals.

Keep Growing and Evolving Your List

Growing an email list isn’t about chasing big numbers or throwing together another freebie just for the sake of it. It’s about building relationships with the right people, and setting up systems that work behind the scenes to nurture, guide, and convert.

Once your funnel’s in place, your focus should shift to staying consistent. Keep publishing valuable content, keep trying new ways to reach your audience, and keep refining what’s already working. The best funnels are never finished – they grow with you.

And if setting all this up feels overwhelming, or you’ve started and then stalled somewhere between “build landing page” and “create welcome sequence”, – you don’t have to figure it all out alone.

Whether you’re starting from scratch or you’ve got a few pieces in place but nothing’s really working yet, we can help you get clear on your strategy and set it all up properly.

Not sure what you need yet? That’s totally fine. Let’s have a chat and work it out.